![Headshot of James Campbell](/media/dpmbkbsr/james-campbell.jpg?cc=0.1781514380448253,0.011342238820059289,0.17656187585216196,0.3426979849901382&width=1440&height=960&quality=90)
James Campbell
Partner | Legal
Jersey
![Headshot of James Campbell](/media/dpmbkbsr/james-campbell.jpg?cc=0.24968221325685575,0.019604558946473175,0.3034670520176996,0.3094383174849376&width=300&height=300&quality=90)
James Campbell
Partner
Jersey
Big things are happening at Ogier. Change is embedded in everything we do. It is redefining our talent, our ways of working, our platforms of delivery, our culture.
Services
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Sectors
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Legal
Corporate and Fiduciary
Consulting
Banking and Finance
Corporate
Dispute Resolution
Employment law
Intellectual Property
Investment Funds
Listing Services
Local Legal Services
Private Wealth
Property law
Regulatory
Relocation Services
Restructuring and Insolvency
Tax
Banking and Finance overview
Asset Finance
CAYLUX Fund Finance
Debt Capital Markets
Derivatives
Fund Finance
Islamic Finance
Leveraged Finance
Listing services
Real Estate Finance
Regulatory
Restructuring and Insolvency
Structured Finance
Sustainable Finance
Corporate overview
Economic Substance
EIIS Services in Ireland
Equity Capital Markets
Insurance and Reinsurance
Listing services
Mergers and Acquisitions
Private Equity
Real Estate Structuring, Acquisitions and Disposals
Regulatory
Technology and Web3
Dispute Resolution overview
Banking Disputes
Corporate and Financial Services Disputes
Crypto Disputes
Enforcement of Judgments and Awards
Fraud and Asset Tracing
Funds Disputes
Insurance Disputes
International Arbitration
Regulatory
Restructuring and Insolvency
Section 238 Shareholder Appraisal Rights
Shareholder and Valuation Disputes
Trusts Disputes and Applications
Investment Funds overview
Hedge Funds
Managers and Sponsors
Private Equity
Real Estate, Infrastructure and Energy Funds
Regulatory
Sustainable Investing and Impact Funds
Technology and Web3
Local Legal Services overview
Cayman Local Legal Services
Channel Islands Local Legal Services
Employment law
Estate Planning, Wills and Probate
Expat services
Family Office
Intellectual Property
Ireland Local Legal Services
Make your Guernsey will online
Make your Jersey lasting power of attorney online
Make your Jersey will online
Notary public services
Property law
Relocation Services
Private Wealth overview
Employee incentives and pensions
Estate Planning, Wills and Probate
Family Office
Make a Jersey lasting power of attorney online
Make your Guernsey will online
Make your Jersey will online
Private Wealth and ESG
Private Wealth and Jersey Private Funds
Relocation Services
Trusts Advisory Group
Accounting and Financial Reporting Services - Ogier Global
Cayman Islands AML/CFT training - Ogier Global
Corporate Services - Ogier Global
Debt Capital Markets - Ogier Global
Fund Services - Ogier Global
Governance Services - Ogier Global
Investor Services - Ogier Global
Ogier Connect - Ogier Global
Private Wealth Services - Ogier Global
Real Estate Services - Ogier Global
Regulatory and Compliance Services - Ogier Global
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
Ogier provides practical advice on BVI, Cayman Islands, Guernsey, Irish, Jersey and Luxembourg law through our global network of offices across the Asian, Caribbean and European timezones. Ogier is the only firm to advise on this unique combination of laws.
Keep up to date with industry insights, analysis and reviews. Find out about the work of our expert teams and subscribe to receive our newsletters straight to your inbox.
Fresh thinking, sharper opinion.
We get straight to the point, managing complexity to get to the essentials. Our global network of offices covers every time zone.
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Components.General.Banners.BannerComponentVm
Insight
22 April 2020
Jersey
4 min read
Private wealth structures are not immune from insolvency. Here we examine the Jersey and Guernsey position from the trustee's perspective and consider the issues with which a trustee needs to be familiar.
Test for insolvency
To talk of an insolvent trust is, of course, inaccurate. A trust is not a separate legal entity and cannot, as a matter of law, be insolvent. The accounts of a trust will have been prepared as if it is a separate legal entity, but the assets and liabilities disclosed by those accounts are, in fact, the assets and liabilities of the trustee and it is to the trustee that creditors will have recourse, unless security has been granted by a trustee over the trust assets.
To determine whether a trust is or is not insolvent, the cash-flow test applies, namely the inability of the trustee to meet its debts as trustee as they fall due out of the trust property.
Change in duties
Insolvency brings about a shift towards the interests of the creditors analogous to that seen in company law and a trust that becomes insolvent should thereafter be administered on the basis that it is insolvent, treating the creditors, rather than the beneficiaries, as the persons with the economic interest in the trust. This will apply as much to third parties holding fiduciary powers in relation to the trust as it does to the trustee.
Therefore, once there is an insolvency or likely insolvency of a trust, the trustee and all those holding fiduciary powers in relation to the trust can only exercise those powers in the interests of the creditors. As the Jersey Royal Court stated in Re Z Trusts [2015] JRC 196C:
"The trustee or fiduciary of such a trust would be wise therefore to exercise their powers either with the consent of all of the creditors or under directions given by the Court".
A trust being administered on the basis that it is insolvent, is to be administered for the benefit of the creditors as a class and not for the majority of them, however large that majority may be, in the same way that a liquidator of a company in a creditors’ winding up owes his or her duties to the creditors of the company as a class, not to individual creditors.
What insolvency regime applies?
In the case of an insolvency or probable insolvency of a trust, the starting point for the Royal Court is to supervise the administration of the trust in the interests of the creditors as a body by way of directions given to the trustee holding office[1].
The process to be adopted will depend on the complexity of the issues faced by the trustee. The Royal Court in both Jersey and Guernsey retains discretion and flexibility to address the circumstances of an insolvent trust on its own merits.
It is well established that a trustee cannot be directed by the Court to do something outside the powers conferred upon it by the trust instrument. The trust instrument may contain a power which would allow the trustee to engage an insolvency practitioner to assist it (as necessary) in the process of winding up the trust and, if appropriate, to delegate powers to that insolvency practitioner.
There is precedent for the Court appointing receivers of a trust but it is a power to be exercised very sparingly and to our knowledge has never been done in respect of an insolvent trust. However, the Court's inherent supervisory jurisdiction is "a wide and vibrant jurisdiction"[2] and such an appointment may be appropriate in special circumstances. The Jersey Royal Court has given a few examples of such circumstances[3]:
Where there is a professional trustee in office with no unmanageable conflict, then it would ordinarily be much more cost effective, and therefore in the interest of the creditors, for the trustee to remain in office and to conduct the winding up process under the supervision of the Court. The approach to be adopted will likely depend on the number of claims from third party creditors seeking trust assets to be realised. In Re Z Trusts, the Jersey Royal Court saw little point in engaging a formal process of examining, admitting or rejecting claims in relation to the trusts because, with the exception of one claim, all of the creditor claims were accepted.
Equitable lien
A trustee is entitled to procure payment out of the trust estate or to be indemnified out of the trust estate in respect of debts properly incurred as trustee. This means that a trustee has a claim on the trust assets for the debts which it has incurred as trustee. In order to satisfy such a claim, the trustee has a right of indemnity which is secured by an equitable lien on the trust assets. That equitable lien does not depend on possession, and it normally survives after it has ceased to be a trustee.[4]
Priority rights
The decision of the Court of Appeal in Re Z Trusts [2019] JCA 106 considered important questions regarding the equitable rights of a former trustee and whether those rights have priority over the rights of other claimants to the assets of a trust (including successor trustees) whose liabilities exceed its assets.
The Court of Appeal reached the following conclusions:
Conclusion
Trustees are entitled to expect the assistance of the court in cases of genuine difficulty and administering an insolvent trust certainly meets that criterion. Article 51 of the Trusts (Jersey) Law 1984 and section 69 of the Trusts (Guernsey) Law, 2007 confer a general discretion on the Court to make orders in relation to a trust if it thinks fit. This gives statutory recognition of the Court’s equitable jurisdiction in relation to trusts.
As the Jersey Royal Court said in Jersey Evening Post -v- Al Thani 2002 JLR 542 its "broad purpose is to assist those concerned with the administration of trusts to resolve their differences and to seek judicial guidance or direction in an orderly context but in a relatively informal and flexible manner".
Ogier's dedicated Restructuring and Corporate Recovery team specialises in restructuring and insolvency issues facing all types of structures, including trusts. Find out more here.
[1] Re Z Trusts [2015] JRC 214 and [2015] JRC 196C
[2] Re WW and XX [2011] JRC 231
[3] Re Z Trusts [2015] JRC 214
[4] Investec Trust (Guernsey) Ltd v Glenella Properties Ltd [2018] UKPC 7 and Re Z Trusts [2019] JCA 106
James Campbell
Partner | Legal
Jersey
James Campbell
Partner
Jersey
Contact James
Back
Damian Evans
Partner | Legal
Jersey
Damian Evans
Partner
Jersey
Contact Damian
Back
Oliver Passmore
Partner | Legal
Jersey
Oliver Passmore
Partner
Jersey
Contact Oliver
Back
Katherine Neal
Head of Employee Incentives, Private Wealth Jersey | Legal
Jersey
Katherine Neal
Head of Employee Incentives, Private Wealth Jersey
Jersey
Contact Katherine
Back
Gavin Ferguson
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Gavin Ferguson
Partner
Guernsey
Contact Gavin
Back
Mathew Newman
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Mathew Newman
Partner
Guernsey
Contact Mathew
Back
Josephine Howe
Partner | Legal
Jersey
Josephine Howe
Partner
Jersey
Contact Josephine
Back
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Blocks.SiteBlocks.CookiePolicySiteBlockVm