Catherine Moore
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Catherine Moore
Partner
Guernsey
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Components.General.Banners.BannerComponentVm
Name The use of Private Trust Companies
ON THIS PAGE
ON THIS PAGE
RELATED
When most settlors establish a trust, they use a professional trust company as the trustee. This way they can ensure that their trustees are professionals with experience gained being the trustee of many other trusts. However, while this is an ideal way to proceed for many settlors, many jurisdictions can offer the flexibility of using private trust companies.
The purpose of this guide is to demonstrate the advantages and disadvantages of private trust companies (PTCs) and to give a brief overview of PTCs in Jersey, Guernsey, Cayman and the British Virgin Islands.
What is a private trust company?
A PTC is an entity whose sole purpose is to act as trustee in relation to a specific trust or trusts. Such entities do not provide trust services generally, and it will be a condition that they must not solicit business from the public at large. Whilst in almost all cases, the PTC will be a company, since the introduction of the Foundations (Jersey) Law 2009, there is the possibility of using a Jersey foundation as the PTC.
Practical application
PTCs are valuable in a number of situations, including as trustees of one or more private family trusts, as trustees of commercial trusts and to hold SPVs that are used in financial or other structures.
The most common use of a PTC is to act as trustee of a purpose trust or a discretionary trust which holds shares in a family company. Settlors of such trusts often wish to keep control of the company themselves, and simply desire that the trustees retain such shares. A professional trustee will often be wary of doing so, however, as failure to diversify assets will almost always be a breach of its duty as a trustee as the trustee cannot be said to be acting in the interests of the beneficiaries.
In the past this has been solved by placing express provisions in the trust deed which provides that the trustees shall hold the particular investment and removes all discretion on their part to deal with the investment. Such a provision will only be effective if absolutely unambiguous, and even then the trustees may be left with a residual discretion or the direction may be void for other reasons (for example, public policy).
The PTC may provide the solution.
Advantages and disadvantages
For a settlor, the key advantage of establishing a PTC is the additional element of control which the PTC can provide. Control is particularly an issue where the settlor is from a jurisdiction unfamiliar with the trust concept, as a settlor is often unwilling to give away control of the assets to strangers in another jurisdiction. The settlor and/or his or her family could be the shareholder or shareholders of a PTC and through that shareholding would be able to appoint and dismiss the directors to the PTC. Whilst this is an obvious disadvantage to the professional administrator, the control of the board of the PTC is often a welcome feature for settlors wishing to retain control. However, if the settlor and/or his family were minded to be shareholders of the PTC, the potential tax consequences of that ownership would need to be fully investigated.
Ownership will generally be recommended to be through a purpose trust or a foundation, rather than the settlor himself. A purpose trust is a trust which is established to achieve a non-charitable purpose, which in the present case is likely to be to provide trusteeship services to designated trusts. This holding structure is illustrated in the diagram below:
On a practical level, a PTC ensures more privacy in relation to the trusts, and allows for rapid commercial decisions to be made. The annual costs are often significantly lower than they would be should a public trust company run the trusts.
The PTC does not compromise the validity of the trust structure and its residency for tax purposes, and can provide immediate and long-term tax planning advantages.
The main disadvantage of a PTC is the cost in establishing a PTC structure. On top of the creation of the trust, a company or foundation must be incorporated. The cost would be further increased if a purpose trust or foundation were used to hold the PTC, as illustrated above, however this could solve potential tax problems. That said, if a foundation were to be a private trustee vehicle itself, there would be no need to have any layer on top, as the foundation would be ownerless. As a result of the cost, PTCs are likely only to be attractive in a commercial context or for very large family structures. For the latter, the costs may be outweighed by the advantages of having a dedicated trustee to look after a complex structure and the control provided to the family.
Choice of domicile
Different rules apply to PTCs in each jurisdiction. Each is considered in turn:
Jersey
A Jersey PTC is an incorporated Jersey entity or non-Jersey company whose sole purpose is to provide trust company business in respect of specified trust. A company carrying on trust company business in Jersey is usually required to be licensed and regulated by the Jersey Financial Services Commission (the Commission) under the provisions of the Financial Services (Jersey) Law 1998 (the FSJ Law) paragraph 4 of the Schedule to the Financial Services (Trust Company Business (Exemptions)) (Jersey) Order 2000 (as amended by the Financial Services (Trust Company Business (Exemptions Amendment)) (Jersey) Order 2009) (the Exemptions Order):
“A person being a company-
- the purpose of which is (i) solely to provide trust company business services in respect of a specific trust or trusts; or (ii) to act for that purpose and to act as a member of the council of a foundation or of foundations (otherwise than as a qualified member, as that term is defined by the Foundations (Jersey) Law 2009)
- that does not solicit from or provide trust company business services to the public
- the administration of which is carried out by a registered person registered to carry out trust company business
when providing a service specific in Article 2(4) of the FSJ Law where the name of the company or limited liability company is notified to the Commission.”
The definition of “company” in the FSJ Law is wide enough to include a foundation.
Furthermore, you will note that subparagraph (c) requires the administration of the PTC to be carried out by a body which is registered under the FSJ Law. If this is not complied with then the exemption will not apply.
Certain provisions of the FSJ Law will still apply to PTCs so as to enable to Commission to exercise a supervisory role despite the lack of registration.
The only demand upon a PTC is that its name be notified by letter to the Commission. If the PTC is a Jersey company there is the additional requirement of disclosure to the Commission of the ultimate beneficial owners of the company and information of the trusts of which the company was to be the trustee. If the PTC is incorporated in any other jurisdiction, the rules relating to disclosure of ultimate beneficial ownership would depend on the rules in that other jurisdiction.
The liability of the PTC directors will fall to be assessed in accordance with normal principles, as the duties of the directors are owed to the PTC and not to the underlying trust.
The constitutional documents of the PTC need not mention the names of or refer to the trust(s) which will be involved in the structure.
Guernsey
A Guernsey PTC that provides its services “by way of business” (it charges a fee for acting as trustee) will be carrying on a regulated activity under sections 1(2) and 2(1)(a) of the Regulation of Fiduciaries, Administration Businesses and Company Directors, etc (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law, 2000 (as amended) (the Fiduciaries Law).
Such a corporate trustee has three possible options.
- first, it could seek a full fiduciary licence under the Fiduciaries Law. The initial application to the Guernsey Financial Services Commission (the GFSC) and ongoing regulatory burden is relatively onerous and consequently, this option may not be attractive
- secondly, the PTC could be engaged on terms under which it is not entitled to any fee for acting as trustee. In such a case, it will not be acting "by way of business" and a licence under the Fiduciaries Law would not be required
- thirdly, the PTC could charge a fee for acting as trustee and apply to the GFSC for specific exemption from licensing pursuant to section 3(1)(y) of the Fiduciaries Law
The granting of an exemption from licensing under the Fiduciaries Law is at the discretion of the GFSC. However, the GFSC’s normal practice in respect of PTCs is to adopt requirements analogous to those set out in the Jersey Exemptions Order applicable to PTCs. Accordingly, so long as the three requirements in the Exemptions Order noted above in the section dealing with Jersey apply (mutatis mutandis) to a particular Guernsey PTC, that PTC would be expected to be able to obtain exemption from licensing under the Fiduciaries Law. Application for exemption carries a small fee.
Provided the GFSC grants the exemption, and the PTC does not engage in any other “regulated activities” (for example “trust administration”) as defined in the Fiduciaries Law then it should not be subject to any further regulation in Guernsey under that law.
The constitutional documents of the PTC need not mention the names of or refer to the trust(s) which will be involved in the structure.
Cayman
In the Cayman Islands, companies that carry on trust business are regulated by the Banks and Trust Companies Law (2009 Revision). Typically, such companies are required to be licensed by the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA), but pursuant the Private Trust Companies Regulations, 2008 (the PTC Regulations) made under that Law there is an exemption for PTCs.
Prior to the PTC Regulations coming into force on 15 September 2008, Cayman PTCs had to hold a restricted trust licence. They also had to make substantial disclosure to, and be subject to vetting and ongoing regulation by, CIMA. In addition, their annual accounts had to be audited. Under the PTC Regulations, these requirements have been removed and replaced by a basic registration requirement.
For the purpose of the PTC Regulations, there are the following three requirements for a company to be a “private trust company”:
- it must be a trust company. This requirement is subsumed into the next requirement
- it must only conduct “connected trust business”. (Elsewhere, the PTC Regulations prohibit a trust company from soliciting or receiving contributions in respect of trusts of which it is a trustee from (i) the public or (ii) persons other than those who are, in relation to each other, “connected persons"
- it must be incorporated in the Cayman Islands. No particular form of company is specified; it may be a company limited by shares or by guarantee
“Connected trust business” is defined in the PTC Regulations to mean “trust business in respect of trusts the contributors to the funds of which are all, in relation to each other, connected persons”. Before looking at the meaning of “connected person”, the first observation to be made about this definition is that it looks to the relationship between contributors of the underlying trust assets; it is not concerned with the relationship between the beneficiaries themselves or between the beneficiaries or any contributor.
Suppose a Cayman company is to act as private trustee of a solitary trust. In these circumstances, there should be two contributors who are connected persons: one contributor could be of the person who settles the nominal settled sum, and the other contributor could be the person who settles the substantive property on the trust.
The expression “connected person” is defined broadly. The PTC Regulations provide that person is a connected person in relation to another person if:
- they are in a relationship listed in the Schedule (which covers a wide range of relationships between individuals related by blood or marriage)
- one is contributing to the funds of the trust as the trustee of a trust of which the other is a contributor
- each is in a group of companies (which expression is defined by reference to the Securities Investment Business Law); or
- one is a company and the other is a beneficial owner of shares or other interests of that company or of any other company in the same group of companies
Other requirements for Cayman PTC are as follows:
- the company must register with CIMA by completing a declaration in the approved form and paying an initial registration fee. Thereafter, on or before 31 January every year during the continuation of the registration, it must file with CIMA an annual declaration in the approved form and pay an annual registration fee
- it must use the words “Private Trust Company” or the letters “PTC” in its name. Only private trust companies are entitled to use either of these designations
- it must maintain a registered office at the office of a licensed trust company in the Cayman Islands
- for each relevant trust, it must keep at its registered office up-to-date copies of (i) the trust deed or other document containing or recording the trust, its powers and provisions and (ii) any deed or document varying the trust, its powers or provisions
In addition, Cayman’s anti-money laundering regime applies to a Cayman PTC.
The above deals with what is required of a Cayman PTC. What is not required is the following:
- there is no requirement for a Cayman PTC to have a minimum share capital. Nor is there a requirement for it to appoint local directors or officers
- further, the PTC Regulations do not require a Cayman PTC to disclose to any personal details of the contributors or the beneficiaries
British Virgin Islands
The Financial Services (Exemptions) Regulations 2007 (the Regulations) are intended to clarify what is meant by a PTC and simplify the procedure by placing the onus on the registered agent (a trust company holding a Class I license) to determine whether the proposed PTC meets the criteria.
In accordance with the Regulations, in BVI a private trust company is “a company:
- that is a qualifying BVI company
- that is a limited company within the meaning of the BVI Business Companies Act, 2004
- the memorandum of which states that it is a private trust company”
The definition of a qualifying business company did not come into effect until 1 January 2008, however, the rest of the Regulations came into effect as of 1 August 2007.
The BVI Companies Act 2004 has been altered in advance to allow the phrase "PTC" to be included in the name of a company engaged in such business.
PTCs are to be exempt where they are unremunerated, and fall within the exemption if they are able to satisfy the definition in Part I, section 2 of the Schedule:
“(1) Trust business carried on by a private trust company is unremunerated trust business if no remuneration is payable to, or received by, the private trust company, or any person associated with the private trust company, in consideration for, or with respect to, the services that constitute the trust business.
(2) For the purposes of subparagraph (1), “remuneration” includes money or any other form of property; and it is immaterial whether remuneration is payable or received out of the assets, or underlying assets, of a relevant trust; from the settlor or beneficiary of a relevant trust; or from any other person pursuant to an arrangement with the settlor or beneficiary of a relevant trust.”
Key contacts
-
-
James Campbell
Partner | Legal
Jersey
James Campbell
Partner
Jersey
-
Anthony Partridge
Partner | Legal
Cayman Islands
Anthony Partridge
Partner
Cayman Islands
-
Matt Guthrie
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Matt Guthrie
Partner
Guernsey
-
Josephine Howe
Partner | Legal
Jersey
Josephine Howe
Partner
Jersey
About Ogier
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
Disclaimer
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up