![Headshot of Richard Laignel](/media/ffxpbgpy/richard-laignel.jpg?cc=0.1267005583152272,0.01016292269836266,0.12207118395579276,0.23782522322070485&width=1440&height=960&quality=90)
Richard Laignel
Managing Associate | Legal
Jersey
![Headshot of Richard Laignel](/media/ffxpbgpy/richard-laignel.jpg?cc=0.2301772255147314,0.01504491618755967,0.24599865843812424,0.19843238704495653&width=300&height=300&quality=90)
Richard Laignel
Managing Associate
Jersey
Big things are happening at Ogier. Change is embedded in everything we do. It is redefining our talent, our ways of working, our platforms of delivery, our culture.
Services
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Sectors
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Legal
Corporate and Fiduciary
Consulting
Banking and Finance
Corporate
Dispute Resolution
Employment law
Intellectual Property
Investment Funds
Listing services
Local Legal Services
Accounting and Financial Reporting Services - Ogier Global
Cayman Islands AML/CFT training - Ogier Global
Corporate Services - Ogier Global
Regulatory and Compliance Services - Ogier Global
Sustainable Investment Consulting
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
Ogier provides practical advice on BVI, Cayman Islands, Guernsey, Irish, Jersey and Luxembourg law through our global network of offices across the Asian, Caribbean and European timezones. Ogier is the only firm to advise on this unique combination of laws.
Keep up to date with industry insights, analysis and reviews. Find out about the work of our expert teams and subscribe to receive our newsletters straight to your inbox.
Fresh thinking, sharper opinion.
We get straight to the point, managing complexity to get to the essentials. Our global network of offices covers every time zone.
About us
Corporate social responsibility (CSR)
Diversity, equity and inclusion
Information security
Innovation
Sustainability
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Components.General.Banners.BannerComponentVm
Insight
12 July 2017
Jersey
ON THIS PAGE
RFC 2012 Plc (in liquidation) (formerly The Rangers Football Club Plc) (Appellant) v Advocate General for Scotland (Respondent) (Scotland) [2017] UKSC 45
The Supreme Court has ruled in favour of HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) in the long-running dispute over the use of an employee benefit trust (EBT) arrangement by the company which formerly owned Glasgow Rangers Football Club (Rangers), before it entered into liquidation in 2012. The dispute has commonly come to be known as the "Big Tax Case".
Background
The essence of the arrangement was that Rangers paid monies into the EBT and further into various sub-trusts for the benefit of players and other senior figures within the club. Loans to the total value of around £47m were then made out from the sub-trusts to over 80 players and other staff between 2001 and 2010. The loans were never repaid.
HMRC challenged the tax status of this arrangement on the basis that such loans were, in reality, forms of disguised remuneration. Based on the legislation in place at the time, the approach had the effect of avoiding the PAYE and NIC deductions which would have been applicable if the payments were classed as "salaries" or "wages".
The HMRC challenge went through the tax tribunal system, with both the First Tier Tribunal in 2012 and the Upper Tribunal in 2014 finding in Rangers' favour on the basis that the payments could not be classed as "emoluments" or "earnings" under the legislation in force at the time. This was because the players and other employees had no "absolute legal entitlement" to the money and that repayment of the loans could be demanded at any time.
In 2015 an appeal to the Court of Session overturned the First Tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal verdicts and found in favour of HMRC, ruling that the payments made under the EBTs were indeed taxable earnings as they derived from employment.
The Appeal
In March 2016, BDO LLP as RFC 2012 plc's liquidators, won the right to appeal against the Court of Session ruling. However, on 5 July 2017, the Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the appeal.
The appeal raised a fundamental question about the nature of the income tax charge on employment income namely whether an employee’s remuneration is taxable as his or her emoluments or earnings when it is paid to a third party in circumstances in which the employee had no prior entitlement to receive it himself or herself.
The court took the view that the charge to tax on income extends to money that the employee is entitled to have paid as remuneration irrespective of whether it is paid directly to the employee or to a third party: "Thus, if an employee enters into a contract or contracts with an employer which provide that he will receive a salary of £X and that as part of his remuneration the employer will also pay £Y to the employee’s spouse or aunt Agatha, I can ascertain no statutory purpose for taxing the former but not the latter."
Accordingly, it was deemed that payments by Rangers to the EBT should have been subject to deduction of income tax at source under the PAYE regulations.
In delivering the judgment, Lord Hodge stated that "Parliament in enacting legislation for the taxation of emoluments or earnings from employment has sought to tax remuneration paid in money or money’s worth. No persuasive rationale has been advanced for excluding from the scope of this tax charge remuneration in the form of money which the employee agrees should be paid to a third party, or where he arranges or acquiesces in a transaction to that effect. Having adopted this purposive construction of the legislation, I turn to apply it to the facts of this appeal."
Given the Supreme Court's purposive view of the legislation, it is probable that HMRC will seek to utilise the decision in order to pursue other cases involving EBTs, employer financed retirement benefits schemes and employer loan schemes.
Following the judgment, David Richardson, interim director general of HMRC’s customer compliance group, released a statement which called for employers who have made payments to employees through EBT arrangements to come forward: "The unanimous decision of the Supreme Court supports our view that Employment Benefit Trust avoidance schemes simply do not work. This decision has wide-ranging implications for other avoidance cases and we encourage anyone who’s tried to avoid tax on their earnings to now agree with us the tax owed. HMRC will always challenge contrived arrangements that try to deliver tax advantage never intended by Parliament."
We expect that there will be many more settlements with HMRC as a result of the judgment and we can provide help and guidance in that regard.
Richard Laignel
Managing Associate | Legal
Jersey
Richard Laignel
Managing Associate
Jersey
Contact Richard
Back
James Campbell
Partner | Legal
Jersey
James Campbell
Partner
Jersey
Contact James
Back
Josephine Howe
Partner | Legal
Jersey
Josephine Howe
Partner
Jersey
Contact Josephine
Back
Katherine Neal
Head of Employee Incentives, Private Wealth Jersey | Legal
Jersey
Katherine Neal
Head of Employee Incentives, Private Wealth Jersey
Jersey
Contact Katherine
Back
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Blocks.SiteBlocks.CookiePolicySiteBlockVm