Paddy Murphy
Senior Associate | Legal
Ireland
Senior Associate
Ireland
Big things are happening at Ogier. Change is embedded in everything we do. It is redefining our talent, our ways of working, our platforms of delivery, our culture.
Services
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Sectors
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
We have the expertise to handle the most demanding transactions. Our commercial understanding and experience of working with leading financial institutions, professional advisers and regulatory bodies means we add real value to clients’ businesses.
Legal
Corporate and Fiduciary
Consulting
Banking and Finance
Corporate
Dispute Resolution
Employment law
Intellectual Property
Investment Funds
Listing Services
Local Legal Services
Private Wealth
Property law
Regulatory
Relocation Services
Restructuring and Insolvency
Tax
Banking and Finance overview
Asset Finance
CAYLUX Fund Finance
Debt Capital Markets
Derivatives
Fund Finance
Islamic Finance
Leveraged Finance
Listing services
Real Estate Finance
Regulatory
Restructuring and Insolvency
Structured Finance
Sustainable Finance
Corporate overview
Economic Substance
EIIS Services in Ireland
Equity Capital Markets
Insurance and Reinsurance
Listing services
Mergers and Acquisitions
Private Equity
Real Estate Structuring, Acquisitions and Disposals
Regulatory
Technology and Web3
Dispute Resolution overview
Banking Disputes
Corporate and Financial Services Disputes
Crypto Disputes
Enforcement of Judgments and Awards
Fraud and Asset Tracing
Funds Disputes
Insurance Disputes
International Arbitration
Regulatory
Restructuring and Insolvency
Section 238 Shareholder Appraisal Rights
Shareholder and Valuation Disputes
Trusts Disputes and Applications
Investment Funds overview
Hedge Funds
Managers and Sponsors
Private Equity
Real Estate, Infrastructure and Energy Funds
Regulatory
Sustainable Investing and Impact Funds
Technology and Web3
Local Legal Services overview
Cayman Local Legal Services
Channel Islands Local Legal Services
Employment law
Estate Planning, Wills and Probate
Expat services
Family Office
Intellectual Property
Ireland Local Legal Services
Make your Guernsey will online
Make your Jersey lasting power of attorney online
Make your Jersey will online
Notary public services
Property law
Relocation Services
Private Wealth overview
Employee incentives and pensions
Estate Planning, Wills and Probate
Family Office
Make a Jersey lasting power of attorney online
Make your Guernsey will online
Make your Jersey will online
Private Wealth and ESG
Private Wealth and Jersey Private Funds
Relocation Services
Trusts Advisory Group
Accounting and Financial Reporting Services - Ogier Global
Cayman Islands AML/CFT training - Ogier Global
Corporate Services - Ogier Global
Debt Capital Markets - Ogier Global
Fund Services - Ogier Global
Governance Services - Ogier Global
Investor Services - Ogier Global
Ogier Connect - Ogier Global
Private Wealth Services - Ogier Global
Real Estate Services - Ogier Global
Regulatory and Compliance Services - Ogier Global
Our sector approach relies on smart collaboration between teams who have a deep understanding of related businesses and industry dynamics. The specific combination of our highly informed experts helps our clients to see around corners.
Ogier provides practical advice on BVI, Cayman Islands, Guernsey, Irish, Jersey and Luxembourg law through our global network of offices across the Asian, Caribbean and European timezones. Ogier is the only firm to advise on this unique combination of laws.
Keep up to date with industry insights, analysis and reviews. Find out about the work of our expert teams and subscribe to receive our newsletters straight to your inbox.
Fresh thinking, sharper opinion.
We get straight to the point, managing complexity to get to the essentials. Our global network of offices covers every time zone.
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Components.General.Banners.BannerComponentVm
Insight
03 April 2024
Ireland
2 min read
In February 2020, the Corporate Enforcement Authority (CEA) initiated an investigation regarding the Football Association of Ireland (FAI) seizing over 250,000 documents, including the email inbox of the former Irish football team CEO, John Delaney.
After being added as a notice party to the proceedings, Mr Delaney claimed privilege over 1,123 digital and several physical documents, asserting Legal Advice Privilege (LAP) over 163 documents and Litigation Privilege (LP) for the remainder. Relying on a unique provision of the Companies Act 2014 (the Act) (s. 795), the CEA sought a determination from the High Court for an assessment of the privilege status of the documents. In adopting those procedures, the Court appointed two independent barristers to assist it to determine if the information was privileged.
Legal Professional Privilege (LPP) is a rule of evidence that grants a party the legal right to withhold information that they would otherwise be compelled to provide.
There are two types of privilege: LAP which protects communications between solicitor and client made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice and LP, which protects communications made for the purpose of engaging in litigation. The common characteristic of both is confidentiality
The High Court rejected Mr Delaney's arguments and found that insufficient evidence had been presented to support his claims of privilege. Additionally, the Court found that in respect of a number of documents Mr Delaney had failed to demonstrate that privilege belonged solely to him, rather than to the FAI.
The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court decision, rejecting claims by Mr Delaney that the High Court was obliged to review each document individually and was bound to follow the report of the independent barristers appointed to assist the Court.
Any party seeking to appeal to the Supreme Court from the Court of Appeal, must show that the case raises a point of law of general public importance or that an appeal is justified in the interest of justice[1]. For direct appeals from the High Court to the Supreme Court, the party must additionally demonstrate that the appeal presents exceptional circumstances that warrant the granting of leave to appeal[2].
The Supreme Court issued a written decision, which held that it was "not in the interest of justice" to grant leave to appeal, to do so, would "allow a hearing of arguments already ventilated in both the High Court and the Court of Appeal".[1]
The Supreme Court acknowledged Mr Delaney's assertion that the Court of Appeal decision raised issues of public importance regarding search warrant execution and privilege. However, it clarified that while the procedures were novel, the issues regarding LPP were not unusual or of significant complexity or public importance.
The Supreme Court clarified that the Court’s divergence from the assessor's recommendations was “quintessentially a matter” for the Court of Appeal to determine and did not raise issues of public importance.
This decision has brought an end to a long-running action that arose from the seizure of over 250,000 documents from the FAI’s offices. The CEA is expected to continue with its inquiry into the FAI, armed with access to all emails from Mr Delaney's FAI email inbox and other hard copy documents.
This decision emphasises that any party claiming LLP must provide evidence to support their claim. The burden lies with the party making the claim, and failure to meet the burden will result in the claim being rejected.
For more information please contact our Sports experts in Ireland via their contact details below.
[1] In the Matter of the Companies Act, 2014 Between: Corporate Enforcement Authority v Cumann Peile Na H-Éireann “The Football Association of Ireland” (Respondent) and John Delaney (Notice Party).
[1] Article 34.5.3 of the Constitution.
[2] Article 34.5.4 of the Constitution.
Paddy Murphy
Senior Associate | Legal
Ireland
Senior Associate
Ireland
Contact Paddy
Back
Eoin McAuley
Trainee Solicitor | Legal
Ireland
Trainee Solicitor
Ireland
Contact Eoin
Back
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up
No Content Set
Exception:
Website.Models.ViewModels.Blocks.SiteBlocks.CookiePolicySiteBlockVm